Why environmental impact assessments often fail
Keywords:
Biodiversity protection, conservation, environmental threats, habitat loss, strategic environmental assessment, threatened speciesAbstract
The environmental impact assessment (EIA) is a nearly universal instrument intended to limit or to offset the environmental tolls of development projects. Here, I describe some of the key shortcomings of EIAs in terms of their real-world application, especially in developing nations that harbor much of the world’s imperiled biodiversity. A surprisingly large number of EIAs suffer from major inaccuracies and some are green-lighting projects that will have serious environmental and societal costs. I summarize by proposing eight strategies to help improve the conservation capacities of EIAs.References
ALVAREZ-CASTANEDA, T., AND W. Z. LIDICKER, JR. 2015. Managing coexistence for bats and wind turbines. Therya 6:505-513.
ANON. 2013. Strategic environmental assessment. The World Bank (https://www.worldbank.org/en/topic/environment/brief/strategic-environmental-assessment).
ANON. 2018. Tapanuli orangutan: A follow-up letter to Indonesian President Joko Widodo. Press release, Alliance of Leading Environmental Researchers and Thinkers (http://alert-conservation.org/tapanuli-orangutan-a-followup-letter-to-indonesian-president-joko-widodo/).
ALAMGIR, M., M. J. CAMPBELL, S. SLOAN, M. GOOSEM, G. R. CLEMENTS, M. I. MAHMOUD, AND W. F. LAURANCE. 2017. Economic, socio-political and environmental risks of road development in the tropics. Current Biology 27:R1130–R1140.
ALAMGIR, M., M. J. CAMPBELL, S. SLOAN, W. E. PHIN, AND W. F. LAURANCE. 2018. Road risks and environmental impact assessments in Malaysian road infrastructure projects. Jurutera: The Institution of Engineers, Malaysia, February, pp. 13-16.
ARKERT, J. 2021. EIA. The Green Connection (https://thegreenconnection.org.za/are-eias-worth-the-paper-its-written-on/).
BARBER, C. P., M. A. COCHRANE, C. M. SOUZA, JR., AND W. F. LAURANCE. 2014. Roads, deforestation, and the mitigating effect of protected areas in the Amazon. Biological Conservation 177:203-209.
BROWN, J. J., K. LIMBURG, J. WALDMAN, K. STEPHENSON, E. GLENN, F. JUANES, AND A. JORDAAN. 2012. Fish and hydropower on the U.S. Atlantic coast: failed fisheries policies from half-way technologies. Conservation Letters, https://doi.org/10.1111/conl.12000.
BURGIN, C. J., J. COLELLA, P. KAHN, AND N. UPHAM. 2018. How many species of mammals are there? Journal of Mammalogy 99:1–14.
CLEMENTS, G. R., A. J. LYNAM, D. GAVEAU, W. L. YAP, S. LHOTA, M. GOOSEM, S. G. LAURANCE, AND W. F. LAURANCE. 2014. Where and how are roads endangering mammals in Southeast Asia’s forests? Plos One 9:e115376.
COCHRANE, S. M. V., E. MATRICARDI, I. NUMATA, AND P. A. LEFEBVRE. 2017. Landsat-based analysis of mega dam flooding impacts in the Amazon compared to associated environmental impact assessments: Upper Madeira River example 2006-2015. Remote Sensing Applications 7:1-8.
DULAC, J. 2013. Global land transport infrastructure requirements: estimating road and railway infrastructure capacity and costs to 2050. International Energy Agency. Washington, U.S.A.
DUPUY, K., AND A. WILLIAMS. 2016. Deciding over nature: corruption and environmental impact assessments. Chr. Michelsen Institute. Bergen, Norway.
FEARNSIDE, P. M., AND P. M. L. GRAÇA. 2006. BR-319: Brazil’s Manaus-Porto Velho Highway and the potential impact of linking the arc of deforestation to central Amazonia. Environmental Management 38:705-716.
FINER, M., AND C. N. JENKINS. 2012. Proliferation of hydroelectric dams in the Andean Amazon and implications for Andes-Amazon connectivity. PLoS ONE 7:e35126.
FOE. 2019. Stop KUR-World. Friends of the Earth (FOE) Far North Queensland (https://www.foefnq.org.au/stop_kur_world).
GARRARD, G. E., S. A. BEKESSY, M. A. MCCARTHY, AND B. A. WINTLE. 2008. When have we looked hard enough? A novel method for setting minimum survey effort protocols for flora surveys. Austral Ecology 33:986-998.
GARRARD, G. E., S. A. BEKESSY, M. A. MCCARTHY, AND B. A. WINTLE. 2015. Incorporating detectability of threatened species into environmental impact assessment. Conservation Biology 29:216-225.
GOOSEM, M. 2008. Rethinking road ecology. Pages 445-449, in Living in a Dynamic Tropical Forest Landscape (Stork, N., and S. Turton, eds.). Blackwell Publishing. Oxford, U.K.
GRAY, T., N. E., A. J. LYNAM, T. SENG, W. F. LAURANCE, B. LONG, L. SCOTSON, AND W. J. RIPPLE. 2016. Wildlife-snaring crisis in Asian forests. Science 355:255-256.
HADDAD, N. M., ET. AL. 2015. Habitat fragmentation and its lasting impact on Earth’s ecosystems. Science Advances 1:e1500052.
JAMAL, H. 2017. Scope, benefits and problems in environmental impact assessment. About Civil.com (https://www.aboutcivil.org/problems-environmental-impact-assessment).
JONES, K. R., O. VENTER, J. R. ALLAN, S. MAXWELL, P. J. NEGRET, AND J. E. M. WATSON. 2018. One-third of global protected land is under intense human pressure. Science 360:788–791.
JONG, H. N. 2021. Deadly landslide hits Indonesian dam project in orangutan habitat, again. Mongabay (https://tinyurl.com/7535btwb).
KAROKARO, A. S. 2021. Death toll rises to 10 after landslide at dam site in orangutan habitat. Mongabay (https://tinyurl.com/6syez55d).
KNEGTERING, E., J. M. DREES, P. GEERTSEMA, AND H. HUITEMA. 2006. Use of animal species data in environmental impact assessments. Environmental Management 36:862-871.
LAURANCE, W. F. 2004. The perils of payoff: Corruption as a threat to global biodiversity. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 19:399-401.
LAURANCE, W. F. 2007. Forest destruction: The road to ruin. New Scientist (https://www.newscientist.com/article/mg19426075.600-forestdestruction-the-road-to-ruin/).
LAURANCE, W. F. 2018. Conservation and the global infrastructure tsunami: Divulge, debate, delay! Trends in Ecology and Evolution 33:568-571.
LAURANCE, W. F., AND I. ARREA. 2017. Roads to riches or ruin? Science 358:442-444.
LAURANCE, W. F., AND D. SALT. 2018. Environmental impact assessments aren’t protecting the environment. Ensia (https://ensia.com/voices/environmental-impact-assessment/).
LAURANCE, W. F., ET AL. 2014. A global strategy for road building. Nature 513:229-232.
LAURANCE, W. F., ET AL. 2015. Reducing the global environmental impacts of rapid infrastructure expansion. Current Biology 25:R259-R262.
LAURANCE, W. F., ET AL. 2020. Tapanuli orangutan endangered by Sumatran hydropower scheme. Nature Ecology and Evolution 4:1438-1439.
LAWRENCE, R. 2018. NGOs and impact investing. KPMG International Cooperative (https://tinyurl.com/36zy9knf).
LEE, N., AND F. WALSH. 1992. Strategic environmental assessment: an overview. Project Appraisal 7:126-136.
LI, J. C. 2008. Environmental impact assessments in developing countries: an opportunity for greater environmental security? Working Paper No. 4, U.S. Agency for International Development. Washingon, U.S.A.
MCCULLOUGH, A. 2017. Environmental Impact Assessments in developing countries: we need to talk about politics. The Extractive Industries and Society 4:448-452
MIDDLE, G., AND I. MIDDLE. 2010. The inefficiency of environmental impact assessment: reality or myth? Impact Assessment and Project Appraisal 28:159-168.
MOMTAZ, S. AND S. M. Z. KABIR. 2018. Evaluating environmental and social impact assessment in developing countries (2nd Edition). Elsevier. London, U.K.
MUKUL, S. A., A. M. RASHID, S. QUAZI, AND M. B. UDDIN. 2012. Local peoples’ response to co-management in protected areas: A case study from Satchari National Park. Bangladesh. Forest Trees and Livelihoods 21:16-29.
RAITER, K. G., H. P. POSSINGHAM, S. PROBER, AND R. J. HOBBS. 2014. Under the radar: Mitigating enigmatic ecological impacts. Trends in Ecology and Evolution 29:635-644.
RICHIE, H., AND M. ROSER. 2021. Extinctions. Our World In Data (https://ourworldindata.org/extinctions; accessed 6 December 2021).
RITTER, C. D., G. MCCRATE, R. H. NILSSON, P. M. FEARNSIDE, U. PALME, AND A. ANTONELLI. 2017. Environmental impact assessment in Brazilian Amazonia: Challenges and prospects to assess biodiversity. Biological Conservation 206:161-168.
RODRIGUEZ, D., A. REYES, AND S. GALLEGOS-SANCHEZ. 2019. Northernmost distribution of the Andean bear (Tremarctos ornatus) in South America, and fragmentation of its associated Andean forest and Paramo ecosystems. Therya 10:161-170.
SLOAN, S., C. JENKINS, L. JOPPA, D. GAVEAU, AND W. F. LAURANCE. 2014. Remaining natural vegetation in the global biodiversity hotspots. Biological Conservation 177:12–24.
SOARES-FILHO, B., ET AL. 2015. Cracking Brazil’s forest code. Science 344:363-364.
SONTER, L., D. HERRERA, D. BARRETT, G. GALFORD, C. MORAN, AND B. SOARES-FILHO. 2017. Mining drives extensive deforestation in the Brazilian Amazon. Nature Communications 8:1013.
TAUBERT, F., R. FISCHER, J. GROENEVELD, S. LEHMANN, M. MULLER, E. RODIG, T. WEIGAND, AND A. HUTH. 2018. Global patterns of tropical forest fragmentation. Nature 554:519–522.
VAN DER REE, R., N. GULLE, K. HOLLAND, AND E. VAN DER GRIFT. 2007. An international review of the use and effectiveness of underpasses and overpasses designed to increase the permeability of roads for wildlife. Pages 423-431, in International Conference on Ecology and Transportation (ICOET) 2007 Proceedings. Little Rock, U.S.A.
WANG, Y., R. K. MORGAN, AND M. CASHMORE. 2003. Environmental impact assessment of projects in the People’s Republic of China: New law, old problems. Environmental Impact Assessment Review 23:543-579.
WARD, M. S., J. SIMMONDS, A. RESIDE, J. WATSON, J. RHODES, H. POSSINGHAM, J. TREZISE, R. FLETCHER, L. FILE, AND M. TAYLOR. 2019. Lots of loss with little scrutiny: the attrition of habitat critical for threatened species in Australia. Conservation Science and Practice 1:e117.
WATSON, J. E. M., D. SHANAHAN, M. DI MARCO, J. ALLAN, W. F. LAURANCE, E. SANDERSON, B. MACKAY, AND O. VENTER. 2016. Catastrophic declines in wilderness areas undermine global environment targets. Current Biology 21:2929–2934.
WINTLE, B. A., T. V. WALSHE, K. M. PARRIS, AND M. A. MCCARTHY. 2012. Designing occupancy surveys and interpreting non-detection when observations are imperfect. Diversity and Distributions 18:417-424.
WOOD, C. 2003. Environmental impact assessment in developing countries: An overview. Conference proceedings: New Directions in Impact Assessment for Development: Methods and Practice. Manchester, U.K.
ZARFL, C, C. BERLEKAMP, F. HE, S. JAHNIG, W. DARWALL, AND K. TOCKNER. 2019. Future large hydropower dams impact global freshwater megafauna. Scientific Reports 9:18531.
Published
Issue
Section
License
THERYA is based on its open access policy allowing free download of the complete contents of the magazine in digital format. It also authorizes the author to place the article in the format published by the magazine on your personal website, or in an open access repository, distribute copies of the article published in electronic or printed format that the author deems appropriate, and reuse part or whole article in own articles or future books, giving the corresponding credits.
